PSPlay Spec Notes
Issue 19  toys · test & specification2026-11-20
COLOUR  /  No. 03

Colour batching in a seasonal toy: the lot that reads pink in March

A seasonal squishy is ordered in one colour and delivered in twelve. The difference is masterbatch, machine and light, and only one of those is the supplier's fault.

DeskPlay spec desk
Filed2026-11-20
ScopeColour
Sections10
A seasonal squishy is ordered in one colour and delivered in twelve. The difference is m
A seasonal squishy is ordered in one colour and delivered in twelve. The difference is masterbatch, machine and light, and only one of those is the supplier's fault.

A seasonal order is a colour order

When a toy exists for six weeks a year, the colour is the product. A customer who orders a pastel assortment and receives a saturated one has no time to re-order, so the colour decision carries the whole season.

That makes the masterbatch a critical path item rather than a purchasing detail. A masterbatch that arrives late is a lot produced with whatever was in the bin, and the bin is where colour drift starts.

The order should therefore fix the masterbatch before the moulding slot is booked, with the carrier and the let-down ratio stated. A supplier who books the slot first and buys the colour second is a supplier who will substitute.

The commercial consequence is that a colour approval sample has to be a production sample. A lab plaque approved in January is not what the March machine will produce.

Let-down ratio and the arithmetic of a shade

A masterbatch is let down into natural resin at a ratio, usually between one and four per cent, and the shade moves with the ratio. A two per cent let-down that is actually run at 1.7 per cent is a visibly lighter toy.

The ratio is set by a gravimetric feeder, and a feeder that is not calibrated drifts through a shift. Drift is slow enough to pass the first article and fast enough to fail the last carton of the day.

The specification should state the ratio with a tolerance, plus a feeder calibration interval. A ratio without a tolerance is a number that only exists on the paperwork.

The check is a weight check on a moulded part against the natural-resin part, taken at the start, the middle and the end of a shift. A part that gains weight through the shift has a feeder that is running rich.

Carrier mismatch and the streaks

A masterbatch has a carrier resin, and the carrier has to be compatible with the base. A polyethylene carrier in a TPR base disperses poorly and produces streaks that look like flow lines.

The streaks are visible on a soft translucent toy as lighter veins, and they are read as a mixing problem when they are a compatibility problem. Changing the mixing time does not fix a carrier mismatch.

The fix is a masterbatch on a compatible carrier, which usually means a TPR-based or a styrenic carrier rather than a polyolefin one. It costs more and it removes the streak.

The specification should name the carrier, not only the colour. A colour reference without a carrier is a reference that a supplier can meet with a masterbatch that will streak.

Machine-to-machine variation in the same plant

Two injection machines in the same plant will produce different shades from the same masterbatch, because barrel temperature, residence time and screw configuration all affect dispersion.

A long residence time at a high temperature degrades the pigment and shifts the shade, usually darker and less saturated. A short residence time on a small machine leaves undispersed pigment, which reads as a duller colour.

The consequence is that a lot split across two machines is a lot with two shades, and the split is invisible in the paperwork. A purchase order that names a quantity and not a machine allocation has allowed it.

The check is a colour measurement on parts from each machine, at the start and the end of the run. A difference above the agreed limit between machines means the lot has to be segregated.

Light and the pink that is a metamerism problem

Two samples that match under a factory fluorescent tube can differ under daylight, and a pastel toy is where metamerism shows most. The customer photographs the toy in daylight and the complaint is about a colour that passed inspection.

Metamerism happens when the pigment combination has a different spectral curve from the reference, so the match holds at one illuminant and fails at another. It is a property of the pigment choice, not of the process.

The fix is to approve the colour under at least two illuminants, usually daylight and a warm white, and to measure the difference under both. A single-illuminant approval is an approval of one lighting condition.

The specification should name the illuminants and the acceptance limits under each, plus the observer angle. A colour standard without an illuminant is not a standard.

Assortment packs and the ratio nobody measures

A seasonal assortment is a set of colours in a stated ratio, and the ratio is what the retailer buys. A pack that should contain equal parts of four colours and contains three of one and five of another is a pack that will be marked down.

The ratio is produced by weighing parts into a bag, and a manual step at that scale drifts. An automatic counter drifts differently, usually by colour because the sensors see pastel tones differently.

The check is a count by colour on a sample of packs, at the start and the end of the packing run. A pack that is correct at the start and wrong at the end has a counting problem rather than a moulding problem.

The specification should state the ratio with a tolerance per pack and per carton. A ratio stated per carton only allows a carton that is correct and a pack that is not.

Colour fastness to saliva, sweat and light

A toy that is mouthed is exposed to saliva, and a pigment that bleeds into saliva is a migration issue rather than a fastness issue. The two are tested differently and both matter for a seasonal toy that is bought for a child.

Light fastness matters for a toy displayed in a window or sold from an open shelf. A pastel that fades is a toy that looks shopworn before it is sold, and the fade is often uneven because the display light is directional.

The test for light is a xenon arc at a stated exposure with a colour difference measured before and after. The test for saliva is a migration cell with a stated time and temperature.

The specification should require both, with the pigment class named. A pigment that meets the colour and fails the fastness is a pigment that will be substituted after the first complaint.

The retained sample and the drift it documents

A colour programme needs a retained sample from each lot, kept in the dark, because the only way to prove drift is to compare against something that has not changed. A shelf of retained samples is the cheapest colour control there is.

The sample should be a production part rather than a plaque, because a plaque does not reproduce the thickness and the surface that the customer sees. A plaque-based standard hides the translucency gradient.

The retained sample also documents the drift for the supplier conversation. A lot that is two units off the master is arguable; a lot that is two units off the previous lot and four off the master is a trend.

The storage has to be dark and cool, because a retained sample that has faded is a standard that has moved. A standard that moves is worse than no standard.

The seasonal calendar and the colour it forces

A six-week season forces a colour decision months earlier, and the decision is made before the year's trend is known. That is why seasonal toys drift toward safe colours and why the assortments look alike.

The practical answer is a colour range approved as a family rather than as single shades, with an allowed variation between them. A family approval lets the supplier use one masterbatch set across the range.

A family approval also reduces the risk of a single shade failing, because the retailer has bought a look rather than a colour. The look survives a small drift; a single shade does not.

The specification should therefore define the family by hue angle and chroma bands rather than by one reference chip. A band is enforceable and a chip is arguable.

Eight lines for a seasonal colour programme

Eight lines carry a seasonal colour: masterbatch reference with its carrier, let-down ratio with a tolerance and a feeder calibration interval, machine allocation with a per-machine colour check, illuminants with limits under each, assortment ratio per pack and per carton, saliva migration and light fastness, and a retained production sample per lot.

The lines are administrative as much as technical, which is what a colour programme is. A shade is produced by a machine and controlled by a record.

The two lines that decide the season are the illuminant pair and the per-pack ratio, because those are the two that a factory inspection under one light and one carton count will miss.

Write the eight, keep the retained samples, and re-approve the whole family when the masterbatch supplier changes. A change of supplier is a change of carrier, and a change of carrier is a change of streak.

The set whose colours are approved as a family, with limits under two illuminants, is the Easter egg squishy stress balls, and that family approval is what survives a six-week season.

Checklist08 items
  • 01Masterbatch reference with its carrier resin named, not only a colour chip.
  • 02Let-down ratio with a tolerance and a feeder calibration interval.
  • 03Machine allocation stated; colour checked per machine at start and end of run.
  • 04Colour approved under two illuminants with a limit under each.
  • 05Assortment ratio stated per pack as well as per carton.
  • 06Saliva migration tested at a stated time and temperature.
  • 07Light fastness by xenon arc with a colour difference before and after.
  • 08One retained production part per lot, stored dark and cool.